The Malkin – Crosby Narrative
The Penguins Game 2 loss to the New York Rangers has brought out the “Evgeni Malkin and Sidney Crosby can’t play together narrative” back to the forefront big time as Crosby and Malkin played nearly seven minutes together 5 v 5.
Heck, there’s even a crowd out there blaming Mike Sullivan’s line juggling, notably his desire to play Malkin with Crosby as one of the main reasons the Penguins lost Game 2.
The Penguins lost Game 2 because of what the Rangers were doing in all three zones not because Sullivan messed with chemistry that included playing Malkin and Crosby together a lot.
I’m not sure who started this talk years ago, but it’s caught on with so many from the fan base to even many in the media. Any time the Penguins lose a playoff game that has Malkin, Crosby playing together a little bit, the Crosby – Malkin talk that they can’t play together hits full steam as it has after Game 2.
Sullivan during a conference call today talked in depth of why he believes Malkin and Crosby can play well together.
Here is the transcript from Sullivan on the question about Malkin – Crosby.
“I’m not sure that they haven’t worked together in the past. I know that they’ve played together at times in the past and at times they’ve been apart. We should have the ability to do both, play them together at times and play them apart at times. They seem to work extremely well on the power play together. When Geno was in the lineup prior to getting hurt our power play was, for probably a 5- or 6-week span, was at 30-percent plus. I’m not one of those guys that throws an opinion around just because they’ve been used at times together in the past and certain people think it will work or it won’t work. I believe that two very good players have the ability to play with anybody and adapt their game accordingly because of their talent. Having said that, I’m not convinced that I’ll use them together moving forward. That’s something that is an option for us. If we do choose to go that route, there’s no reason why two players that are as good as they are cannot work together. They’re two elite players that think the game on a high level, and they have the ability to play a down low game and a fast, speed game off of the rush. That’s really the way I look at it. I know there’s been different schools of thought, theories in the past of how these guys have been used. Another comment that I would have is that I think both of these guys are in a different place than they were in the previous years. They’re a little bit older. They have more experience under their belt. They probably have the benefit of a little bit more perspective because they’ve gone through different experiences. We all learn from our experiences. For me, that’s how you gain wisdom. I think these guys from a mindset standpoint are in a very different place than they have been in the past.” — Mike Sullivan.
Penguin coaches have a lot of reasons to ponder why Malkin is better suited for wing at this point with no reason to breakup the Hagelin – Bonino – Kessel line.
Among one of the obvious reasons is Malkin’s arm/elbow. He is not a shooting presence at all with zero attempts in his first game and a source says it’s difficult for Malkin to take face-off’s in the left dot. Playing down low in the defensive zone also opens the opportunity for more strain on the injury.
Aside from the injury, the Penguins have a major problem in this series in that the Rangers have figured them out in the neutral zone. I’ll be illustrating this more in a Monday post but the Rangers dominating the neutral zone has altered this series in New York being the superior team 5 v 5 that has to be making the advance stats crowd go nuts.
The neutral zone is where Crosby and Malkin playing together comes into play and why they can be really dangerous together in this series in combating the Rangers neutral zone setup.
While this doesn’t go with the narrative, here’s a news flash — the two were excellent together in breaking the Rangers trap and gaining the zone in Game 2 —
Off this zone entry where Malkin draws two Rangers to him along the wall, he gets the puck to Crosby, who gains the zone, pulls up and sets up a trailing Ian Cole for a shot on goal. Conor Sheary was on the ice with Malkin and Crosby, and if that’s Patric Hornqvist, there would surely be a net-front presence (instead of Sheary hanging out on the outside) instead of Lundqvist having a clear view of the shot.
Later in the first period, Malkin and Crosby combine for another zone entry with Malkin drawing two Ranger forwards to him, moves the puck over to an open Crosby down the right side, who gains the zone, and sets up Patric Hornqvist for a quick shot that almost beat Lundqvist.
This is what Crosby and Malkin give you together. Malkin’s ability to break the Rangers structure in the neutral zone and make quick plays along the wall is going to open a ton of space for Crosby.
The Penguins controlled 54% of their shot attempts (5 v 5) when Malkin and Crosby were on the ice together in Game 2. Including the regular season, Crosby and Malkin have played 36:52 together 5 v 5 and the Penguins have controlled 66% of their shot attempts when those two are both on the ice.
Coming off the type of injury Malkin has, anyone wonder that maybe Malkin needs Crosby right now?
When Malkin was on the ice without Crosby at even strength in Game 2, the Penguins controlled just 16% of their shot attempts. When the Sheary – Malkin – Rust line were on the ice together, the Penguins had zero shot attempts.
Sullivan I’m told see’s Patrick Kane To read this insider news, subscribe to get “Inside Access”!
So both Murray and MAF on ice? Hopefully one will be good to go sooner than later. “Hot goalie” lasted one whole game and we seriously need the upgrade.
Anyone else shocked that they sent Sestito down already?
I know I am, figured he was key to this series. Not sure how the Pens can pull this off without him.
nice to see murray is back at practice. i hope we get to see him in game 3.
Me too. On teh bench of course. Because he’s a backup. But I do hope he dresses. Murray is ready! #YogurtKnew
Dan Rosen @drosennhl 1m1 minute ago
Ryan McDonagh on the ice for the start of Rangers’ practice today and in a regular white (contact) jersey.
Bill West @BWest_Trib 2m2 minutes ago
Based on Pens 1st drill of day, Malkin on line w/ Fehr & Sheary. Rust rejoins Kuhnhackl & Cullen.
Fleury is practicing, yes
Huh – that sure sounds familiar.
http://www.nathansfamous.com/contest/hall-of-fame
make sure you keep and eye on the countdown clock Mr.Npl
Trade chubby, sam.
i hope
Chubby and Malkin. That’s the problem with this team. Trade them. Oh, and Maatta. You said all three. Fucking idiot.
too late now
i wanted malkin.maatta bennett tradeto the oilers for the 1st overall pick before they got mcdavid now its too late they wont give him since he played in the nhl and has more value then before draft
McDavid is with Vancouver, stupid. Not to mention – they wouldn’t have done that.
“Maybe Crosby needs Malkin right now”… Agreed… the lack of offence overall was a clear indicator that we are all crazy and these two are the next Hull and Oates. Malkin was tentative to shoot… Sid is a pass 1st guy especially when you have a Malkin type on his line. That will work well lol
Oh… one more thing…. I believe Mlakin stated he didn’t wanna play on the wing. This is usually the biggest case I make for not playing them together. Malkin is better at C than W and some of that may be because he isnt fucking happy as a W…. which I believe he has alluded to a couple times in his career!
My preference sit malkin rest of the playoffs and trade that cancer this summer
Trade chubby, sam.
The pens just need St blurry back for the pens to dominate. He is a 1st ballot hall of famer which means he has been in the top 2 or 3 NHL goaltenders over the past 10 years. He will easily win the pens the series.
Zatkoff is ready.
malkin can’t play with Crosby and st blurry is a hall of fame goalie. That’s all you need to know about the hockey IQ in this town.
I love when you try to talk about literally anyone else’s iq, hockey or otherwise.
He can’t, this isn’t much of a secret. It changes the way they play too much. Crosby is better when he is a threat to shoot, he defers to Malkin and his superior shot at every opportunity. As for you continuing to smack talk MAF after “the hot goalie” was just exposed as the 3rd stringer is his couldn’t be more laughable. You willfully ignore that MAF has been very good the last couple years… correlates directly too significant changes he made personally and with his goalie coach yet you have nothing to say about watching Z get lit up… Read more »
My lines…..with the assumption you can’t break the 2nd line
Kunitz – Crosby – Sheary
Hagelin – Bonino – Kessel
Hornqvist – Malkin – Fehr
Rust – Cullen – Kuhnhackl
My preference is to tell Kessel/Hags to adjust to a new center and play with Malkin….
Kunitz – Crosby – Hornqvist
Hagelin – Malkin – Kessel
Rust – Bonino – Kuhnhackl
Fehr – Cullen – Sheary
I wouldn’t break up the Bonino line. And i wouldn’t break up the line that has had the best possession numbers in hockey before Injury. Malkin gets the leftovers right now, and if he helps the power play, anything he gives you at even strength is gravy. Just the disruption of one of those top three lines going against their third pairing is worth it:
14-87-72
16-71-43
62-13-81
17-7-34
Done and done.
I thought fehr with malkin makes the most sense too. Have fehr just take draws and have malkin play center.
Why would we take Hornqvist off Sids line?
Shouldn’t even be contemplated, zero. I’m with you.
Not to mention the fact that by doing so they’re then playing both Hornqvist and Sheary out of position. Simply Dustin at his finest right there.
D…did you listen to Malkin after the game in his interview? In my translation of what he says, he doesn’t like to juggle back and forth from wing to center and back and forth. He then says he prefers to play center and expects to be back at center next game.
Nothing on MAF?
who cares about st.blurry. what’s the word on murray?
Murray is ready. #YogurtKnew
“Pens v. Rangers” starring Charlie Chaplin
hot dog eating contest 100 year anniversary
Starring NPL
Chubby traded yet?